Skip to content
Independent, non-partisan explainers on elections, parties and parliaments
The Ballot PrimerHow democracy works, explained

Home › Parties & Coalitions

Socialism vs Communism: The Difference Explained

Socialism and communism share the aim of common ownership but differ in scope, in how goods are shared out and, since 1917, in politics. This guide traces the two words from the 1830s to the split in the socialist movement.

Socialism vs Communism: The Difference Explained
Photo: Pexels / Pixabay

The difference between socialism and communism is partly one of scope and partly one of history. Socialism is the broader term: a family of theories and movements that want the main productive assets of a society under social control instead of private ownership. Communism is narrower. It names a classless society with common ownership, goods shared according to need and, in the end, no money and no state; since 1917 it has also named the parties that followed the Bolshevik model.

Two ways the words are told apart

People who separate the two terms usually have one of two things in mind. The first is a sequence inside Marxist theory, in which socialism is an earlier stage and communism the later one. The second is a division between political movements: after the Russian Revolution, communist came to mean a supporter of Bolshevism, while other socialists kept the older name or called themselves social democrats.

Neither usage is universal. Marx himself used socialism, communism and several other terms for the society he expected to follow capitalism, and communist parties have gone on describing themselves as socialists working for socialism.

Where the two words come from

Both words are older than Marxism. Robert Owen's Co-operative Magazine used the word socialists as early as 1827 for those who favoured common ownership of capital, and Pierre Leroux, a follower of Saint-Simon, claimed to have first used socialism in the Paris journal Le Globe in 1832. The word was set against the liberal doctrine of individualism.

Communism derives from the French communisme, built on the Latin communis, common. Restif de la Bretonne used it in 1793 for a social order based on equality and common ownership of property, and John Goodwyn Barmby is credited with the first use in English, around 1840.

In the 1840s the two labels marked a social difference. Friedrich Engels explained in his preface to the 1888 English edition of the Communist Manifesto why he and Marx had not called it a socialist manifesto. In 1847, he wrote, socialists meant the followers of utopian schemes, such as the Owenites in England and the Fourierists in France, or reformers who promised to cure social ills without any danger to capital and profit. Workers who wanted a total change in society called themselves communists. Socialism, as he put it, was then a middle-class movement and communism a working-class one. By 1888 Marxists themselves were using the word socialism in place of communism.

Marx's two phases

The idea of a sequence comes from Marx's Critique of the Gotha Programme, written in 1875. He distinguished a first phase of communist society, as it emerges from capitalism and still carries its marks, from a higher phase. In the first, the means of production are held in common and each producer receives from the common stock in proportion to the labour he has contributed, after deductions for shared funds. Marx accepted that this still leaves people unequal, since individuals differ in strength and in the number of dependants they support.

Only in the higher phase, once the division of labour no longer rules people's lives and production has grown, did he expect society to adopt the rule "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs!" (Karl Marx, Critique of the Gotha Programme).

Marx called both phases communist. It was Lenin, in The State and Revolution (1917), who noted that the first phase is what is usually called socialism, with complete communism arriving only in the higher one. That labelling passed into Marxist usage: socialism as the transitional stage, with pay according to work done, and communism as distribution according to need.

Socialism and communism side by side

QuestionSocialismCommunism
Scope of the termA wide tradition with many schools, Marxist and non-MarxistA specific goal, and the movement of communist parties since 1917
OwnershipThe bulk of the means of production under social, democratic controlCommon ownership of the means of production, distribution and exchange; no private property
Sharing out of goods (Marxist usage)According to work contributedAccording to need
Markets and moneyDisputed; market socialism keeps marketsUltimately no money
Classes and stateViews differ on the role of the stateNo social classes and ultimately no state
RouteReform through elected governments or revolution, depending on the schoolSocial revolution

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy adds a caution about the ownership row. On its definition socialism is not the same thing as state control: where a state runs the economy without itself being democratically controlled by the people who work in it, the result is statism.

How 1917 turned a vocabulary into a split

Until the Russian Revolution, social democrat was a common name for socialists of both the revolutionary and the reformist kind. In March 1918 the Bolsheviks renamed their party the Russian Communist Party. The Communist International was founded in 1919, and the conditions of admission adopted at its second congress in 1920 required every member party to take the name Communist Party, so that workers could tell it apart from the older social democratic and socialist parties.

By the early 1920s communism and social democracy had become the two dominant tendencies in the international socialist movement. The vocabulary of stages survived inside the first of them. The Soviet state was named the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, was governed by a communist party and described itself as a socialist state working towards communism.

How the non-communist side of that split developed is covered in democratic socialism vs social democracy.

Criticisms made of each

Communism in the Bolshevik sense is criticised from outside and inside the socialist tradition. The Stanford entry judges that the revolutionary strategy pursued in Russia and China failed to build socialism and led to a form of authoritarian statism, and that the Soviet system concentrated political and economic power in a single party and trampled on civil and political liberties. In 1951 the Socialist International, at its first congress in Frankfurt, declared that communism falsely claimed a share in the socialist tradition.

Communists made the opposite charge. The 1920 conditions of admission accused the old social democratic and socialist parties of having betrayed the working class.

Socialism in the wider sense faces criticism of its economics. Critics argue that a central planner cannot gather the information that producers and consumers hold, that computing a workable plan may be beyond the capacity of any planners, and that enterprises without the threat of bankruptcy or the prospect of profit innovate less. That debate, and the socialist criticisms of capitalism that prompted it, are set out in socialism vs capitalism.

Common questions

Is communism a type of socialism?

In most classifications, yes. Communism grew out of the nineteenth-century socialist movement and is usually treated as one current within it, distinguished by its goal of a classless society and its commitment to revolution.

Did Marx separate socialism from communism?

Not by name. In 1875 he described a first and a higher phase of communist society; Lenin, writing in 1917, equated the first phase with what was by then usually called socialism.

Was the Soviet Union socialist or communist?

Its official name was the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, and its Communist Party was the sole governing party until 1990. In its own terms it was a socialist state working towards communism, which it never claimed to have reached.

What is the difference in one sentence?

Socialism is the general idea of social ownership of productive assets, pursued in many ways; communism is the specific aim of a classless, stateless society sharing goods by need, and the party movement that has pursued it since 1917.

Sources

  1. Karl Marx, Critique of the Gotha Programme, part I (Marxists Internet Archive)
  2. Friedrich Engels, preface to the 1888 English edition of the Communist Manifesto (Marxists Internet Archive)
  3. V. I. Lenin, The State and Revolution, chapter 5 (Marxists Internet Archive)
  4. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Socialism
  5. Wikipedia, Communism
  6. Wikipedia, Socialism

The Ballot Primer is independent and non-partisan. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Keep reading