Skip to content
Independent, non-partisan explainers on elections, parties and parliaments
The Ballot PrimerHow democracy works, explained

Home › Parliament & Government

Prorogation: What It Means When Parliament Is Prorogued

Prorogation ends a session of Parliament without ending the Parliament itself. Here is how it works, what happens to unfinished bills, and what the Supreme Court decided about the 2019 prorogation.

Prorogation: What It Means When Parliament Is Prorogued
Photo: derwiki / Pixabay

Prorogation is the formal ending of a session of the UK Parliament. It is carried out in the name of the monarch, on the advice of the prime minister, and it stops parliamentary business until the next session begins with the State Opening of Parliament. Prorogation does not end the Parliament itself and does not lead to an election: MPs keep their seats and the government stays in office.

What prorogation does

The life of a Parliament, from one general election to the next, is divided into sessions, each usually lasting about a year. Prorogation brings a session to a close. In its 2019 judgment on the subject the Supreme Court summarised the effects:

  • while Parliament is prorogued, neither House can meet, debate or pass legislation;
  • most bills that have not completed their passage are lost;
  • the government remains in office and can still make delegated legislation, but it cannot get new Acts passed or win approval for new spending.

In modern practice the gap is short, a matter of days before the new session opens. Parliament is always prorogued to a definite day. The ceremony begins in the House of Lords, where commissioners act in the sovereign's name and a speech reviewing the session is read. If Parliament is needed urgently while prorogued, it can be recalled by proclamation.

Who prorogues Parliament

Prorogation is a prerogative power: one of the powers that legally belong to the Crown. It is exercised by the monarch on the advice of the Privy Council, and in practice the decision is the prime minister's. The monarch does not use personal discretion. Neither House votes on it, which is the main difference from an ordinary break in sittings.

Prorogation, dissolution and adjournment

Three different things can stop Parliament sitting, and they are easily confused.

ProrogationDissolutionAdjournment or recess
What it endsA session of ParliamentThe Parliament itselfA sitting; a recess is a longer break within a session
Who decidesThe monarch, on the prime minister's adviceThe monarch, at the prime minister's request; otherwise automatic five years after the Parliament first metEach House, by passing a motion
Effect on membersMPs keep their seatsA general election follows 25 working days laterMPs keep their seats
Effect on businessNo sittings; most unfinished bills fallAll business endsThe House does not sit, but committees can meet and written questions must still be answered
What comes nextA new session, opened by the State Opening of ParliamentA newly elected ParliamentBusiness resumes where it stopped

What happens to unfinished bills

A bill that has not received royal assent by prorogation normally falls and has to start again in the next session. The exception is carry-over. A minister can table a carry-over motion and, if the Commons agrees, the named government bill continues in the new session. A carried-over bill has 12 months from its first reading in the Commons to complete its passage, and a bill may not be carried over twice. Our guide to how a bill becomes law sets out the stages a bill must finish in time.

The 2019 prorogation and the Supreme Court

Prorogation is usually routine, but it has sometimes been used in contested ways. In 1948, for instance, a special short session was held, opened on 14 September and prorogued on 25 October, so that the bill which became the Parliament Act 1949 could meet the timetable for being passed without the consent of the Lords. The most important modern case came in 2019.

What happened

On 28 August 2019 an Order in Council was made, on the prime minister's advice, for Parliament to be prorogued from a date between 9 and 12 September until 14 October 2019. The ceremony took place in the early hours of 10 September. The UK was then due to leave the European Union on 31 October 2019.

The decision was challenged in the courts. On 6 September the High Court in London held that the issue was not one for the courts to decide ("non-justiciable"). On 11 September the Inner House of the Court of Session in Edinburgh reached the opposite view and held the prorogation unlawful. Both cases went to the Supreme Court, which heard them together from 17 to 19 September as R (Miller) v The Prime Minister and Cherry v Advocate General for Scotland.

What the court decided

Eleven justices sat, the largest panel the court can assemble. On 24 September 2019 they gave a single unanimous judgment, delivered by Lady Hale and Lord Reed. It answered four questions.

  1. Could the courts rule on it? Yes. The courts have long decided whether a prerogative power exists and how far it extends, and this was a question about the limits of the power.
  2. What is the limit? A decision to prorogue will be unlawful "if the prorogation has the effect of frustrating or preventing, without reasonable justification, the ability of Parliament to carry out its constitutional functions as a legislature and as the body responsible for the supervision of the executive".
  3. Was the limit crossed? Yes. Parliament would have been prevented from sitting for five of the eight weeks between the end of the summer recess and 31 October, and no reasonable justification for a prorogation of that length had been put before the court.
  4. What followed? The advice was unlawful, and so the Order in Council and the prorogation itself were "unlawful, null and of no effect". In the court's words, "Parliament has not been prorogued."

Parliament resumed sitting the next day, 25 September. It was later prorogued for six days, from 8 to 14 October, before a new session opened.

The judgment was about the effect of the prorogation on Parliament, not about the merits of leaving the European Union. Legal opinion on it was divided. Some constitutional scholars saw it as an orthodox application of principle that reaffirmed parliamentary sovereignty; others argued that prorogation is governed by convention, not law, and that the court had stepped into politics. The case is a leading example of judicial review of a prerogative power.

The Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022

This Act, which received royal assent on 24 March 2022, is sometimes mentioned alongside the 2019 case, but it deals with a different power. It repealed the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011 and revived the prerogative power to dissolve Parliament and call a new one. Section 3 says that a court or tribunal may not question the exercise of those powers, and section 4 provides that a Parliament is dissolved automatically on the fifth anniversary of the day it first met, if it has not been dissolved sooner.

The Act's main provisions concern dissolution, not prorogation. The rule set out by the Supreme Court in 2019 therefore still describes the legal limit on proroguing Parliament. How these powers sit within the wider system is covered in our explainer on the UK constitution.

Common questions

What does it mean to prorogue Parliament?

To prorogue Parliament is to end the current session. Neither House sits until the next session opens, and most unfinished bills fall, but MPs keep their seats and no election is held.

Is prorogation the same as dissolution?

No. Prorogation ends a session; dissolution ends the Parliament and is followed by a general election. An adjournment or recess is different again: it is a break agreed by each House, during which committees can still meet.

Who has the power to prorogue Parliament?

The power belongs to the Crown and is exercised by the monarch on the advice of the prime minister. Parliament itself does not vote on it.

Was the 2019 prorogation lawful?

No. On 24 September 2019 eleven justices of the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the advice to prorogue Parliament for five weeks was unlawful and that the prorogation was null and of no effect.

Sources

  1. The National Archives: R (Miller) v The Prime Minister; Cherry v Advocate General for Scotland [2019] UKSC 41
  2. Supreme Court: case UKSC 2019/0192
  3. Wikipedia: Prorogation in the United Kingdom
  4. Wikipedia: R (Miller) v The Prime Minister and Cherry v Advocate General for Scotland
  5. legislation.gov.uk: Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022
  6. Wikipedia: Dissolution of the Parliament of the United Kingdom

The Ballot Primer is independent and non-partisan. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Keep reading