Skip to content
Independent, non-partisan explainers on elections, parties and parliaments
The Ballot PrimerHow democracy works, explained

Home › Rights & the Constitution

The Human Rights Act 1998: A Summary of What It Does

The Human Rights Act lets people rely on European Convention rights in UK courts. Here is what the Act does, how its key sections work, which rights it covers and why it has nothing to do with the EU.

The Human Rights Act 1998: A Summary of What It Does
Photo: succo / Pixabay

The Human Rights Act 1998 is the Act of Parliament that makes the rights in the European Convention on Human Rights enforceable in UK courts. It requires public authorities to respect those rights, tells courts to read other laws compatibly with them where possible, and lets senior courts declare that an Act of Parliament is incompatible with them. It received royal assent on 9 November 1998 and came into force on 2 October 2000.

What the Act does

The UK has been a party to the European Convention on Human Rights since the early 1950s. Before the Act, however, a person who believed their Convention rights had been breached had to take the case to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. The government's 1997 white paper, "Rights Brought Home", said that this took on average five years and cost on average £30,000.

The Act changed that in three main ways:

  1. it makes it unlawful for public authorities to act incompatibly with Convention rights, and gives people a remedy in UK courts if they do;
  2. it requires all legislation to be read, as far as possible, in a way that fits with those rights;
  3. it sets out what happens when an Act of Parliament cannot be read that way.

People keep the right to apply to the Strasbourg court once they have been through the UK courts.

The key sections

  • Section 2. A court or tribunal deciding a question about a Convention right "must take into account" relevant judgments and decisions of the Strasbourg institutions.
  • Section 3. "So far as it is possible to do so, primary legislation and subordinate legislation must be read and given effect in a way which is compatible with the Convention rights."
  • Section 4. If a senior court is satisfied that a provision of an Act is incompatible with a Convention right, "it may make a declaration of that incompatibility".
  • Section 6. "It is unlawful for a public authority to act in a way which is incompatible with a Convention right."

Interpretation and declarations of incompatibility

Section 3 applies to legislation whenever it was passed. But it does not let judges override Parliament: the section itself says it does not affect the validity or continuing operation of incompatible primary legislation. Where a compatible reading is impossible, the higher courts, from the High Court upwards, may make a declaration of incompatibility under section 4. Such a declaration does not affect the validity of the provision and is not binding on the parties to the case. The law stays in force, and it is for ministers and Parliament to decide whether to change it. Section 10 allows a minister to amend the offending legislation by a fast-track "remedial order".

In this way the Act seeks to protect rights while keeping parliamentary sovereignty, a balance discussed in our explainer on the UK constitution. Courts can, by contrast, strike down secondary legislation.

Public authorities

Under section 6 a "public authority" includes courts and tribunals and anyone whose functions are of a public nature. It does not include either House of Parliament. An authority has a defence if an Act of Parliament left it no choice but to act as it did. Under section 7 only a victim of the unlawful act can bring a claim, and under section 8 a court may grant whatever remedy within its powers it considers just and appropriate, which can include damages. Claims are often brought by way of judicial review.

Section 19 adds a check at the start of the law-making process: a minister introducing a bill must state that it is compatible with Convention rights, or say that the government wishes to proceed even though no such statement can be made.

The rights the Act protects

The "Convention rights" are set out in Schedule 1 to the Act: Articles 2 to 12 and 14 of the Convention, together with rights from two of its protocols.

ArticleRightIn brief
Article 2Right to lifeEveryone's right to life must be protected by law
Article 3Prohibition of tortureNo torture, and no inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment
Article 4Prohibition of slavery and forced labourNo slavery, servitude or compulsory labour
Article 5Right to liberty and securityNo one may be detained except in the cases, and by the procedure, the law allows
Article 6Right to a fair trialA fair and public hearing within a reasonable time; the presumption of innocence
Article 7No punishment without lawNo conviction for an act that was not an offence when it was done
Article 8Right to respect for private and family lifeCovers private life, family life, home and correspondence
Article 9Freedom of thought, conscience and religionIncludes the freedom to hold beliefs and to practise them
Article 10Freedom of expressionFreedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart information and ideas
Article 11Freedom of assembly and associationPeaceful assembly, and association with others, including joining trade unions
Article 12Right to marryThe right to marry and to found a family
Article 14Prohibition of discriminationThe Convention rights must be secured without discrimination
Protocol 1, Article 1Protection of propertyPeaceful enjoyment of possessions
Protocol 1, Article 2Right to educationNo one may be denied the right to education
Protocol 1, Article 3Right to free electionsFree elections at reasonable intervals by secret ballot
Protocol 13, Article 1Abolition of the death penaltyNo one may be condemned to death or executed

Schedule 1 also contains three technical provisions, Articles 16 to 18, on the political activity of aliens, abuse of rights and the use of restrictions on rights.

Absolute, limited and qualified rights

The rights do not all work in the same way. Guides to the Act usually sort them into three groups.

  • Absolute rights can never be restricted, whatever the circumstances. The ban on torture and inhuman or degrading treatment in Article 3 is the clearest example. The right to hold a belief is also absolute.
  • Limited rights can be restricted only in specific situations that the Act itself sets out. Article 5 is an example: detention after conviction by a court is lawful if the proper procedure is followed.
  • Qualified rights can be interfered with to protect other people's rights or the wider public interest. They include Article 8 (private and family life), Article 9 so far as it covers manifesting a religion or belief, Article 10 (expression) and Article 11 (assembly and association).

An interference with a qualified right is lawful only if it is allowed by law, pursues a legitimate aim such as national security, public safety, the prevention of crime or the protection of health, and is necessary in a democratic society, meaning that it goes no further than needed. Our explainer on freedom of speech in the UK shows how that balance works in practice.

Not an EU law

The Convention and the Strasbourg court are often mistaken for European Union institutions. They are not. The Convention is a treaty of the Council of Europe, a separate organisation founded in 1949, which has 46 member states. It was opened for signature in 1950 and came into force in 1953. The European Court of Human Rights, which sits in Strasbourg, belongs to the Council of Europe. The EU's court is the Court of Justice of the European Union in Luxembourg, and the two are not institutionally connected.

Leaving the EU in 2020 therefore did not take the UK out of the Council of Europe or the Convention, and the Human Rights Act remained in force.

Proposals to replace the Act

Whether the Act strikes the right balance between courts and Parliament has long been argued over. Critics have argued that it ties UK courts too closely to the Strasbourg court and have proposed a "British Bill of Rights"; supporters reply that it lets people enforce their rights at home while leaving the last word with Parliament. A government bill to replace the Act, the Bill of Rights Bill, was introduced in the Commons on 22 June 2022. It did not reach a second reading, and on 27 June 2023 the then Justice Secretary confirmed that the government would not proceed with it.

Common questions

What is the Human Rights Act in simple terms?

It is a UK law that lets people rely on the rights in the European Convention on Human Rights in UK courts. It also makes it unlawful for public authorities to act in a way that is incompatible with those rights.

When did the Human Rights Act 1998 come into force?

The Act received royal assent on 9 November 1998 and came into force on 2 October 2000.

Can a court strike down an Act of Parliament under the Human Rights Act?

No. A senior court can make a declaration of incompatibility, but the Act of Parliament stays in force and it is for Parliament to decide whether to change it. Courts can strike down secondary legislation.

Is the Human Rights Act part of EU law?

No. It gives effect to the European Convention on Human Rights, a treaty of the Council of Europe, which is a separate body from the European Union. Leaving the EU did not repeal the Act.

Sources

  1. legislation.gov.uk: Human Rights Act 1998, Schedule 1 (the Articles)
  2. legislation.gov.uk: Human Rights Act 1998, sections 3 to 5
  3. legislation.gov.uk: Human Rights Act 1998, section 6
  4. Wikipedia: Human Rights Act 1998
  5. Wikipedia: European Convention on Human Rights
  6. Citizens Advice: When can a public authority interfere with your human rights?

The Ballot Primer is independent and non-partisan. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Keep reading